Season 9: PLAYER ROLES MEETS FORMATION MATTERS EPISODE 28: 5-4-1B meets Player Roles

We’re almost at the final lap as we enter the penultimate formation within season 9… The 5-4-1B is a formation that many will consider to be the orthodox one that we’re all used to as fans. Although it does have a similarity in terms of how it looks in its base form to the 5-2-3 (which is coming up in our final episode), it is more of a formation that consists of the same set up as its ‘A’ side counterpart with the major difference being in the midfield region where we have more of a flat 4 rather than a diamond.

DEFENCE

If it’s one thing that I’ve probably realized is that we may have left ourselves open in terms of the lesser rated players being utilized for the ‘5 at the back’ formations. Nevertheless, this is a perfect time to demonstrate how effective a balanced XI will be as long as you’ve got the right players within the set up. And we definitely have the right GK in the Spanish shot stopper whom many have seem to forgot how brilliant of a player he was in his prime… De Gea started his career at Atletico Madrid where he got a reputation for being an exceptional long range shot stopper which was one of the catalyst for Sir Alex Ferguson chosing to purchase him for Manchester United back in 2011. He arrived at Old Trafford as a skinny 20 year old who struggled with dealing with any physical scenarios around his 6 yard box. That weakness led him to lose his spot to Anders Lindegaard for a short period of time. David didn’t get insecure though and decided to tap into his inner Cristiano Ronaldo and got into the gym to bulk up in order to deal with the physical requirements of being a GK in the Premier League.

De Gea went on to win United’s player of the season for 3 consecutive years during a time frame where he was well regarded as the best GK on the planet, showcasing his quite RIDICULOUS reflexes and producing ‘save of the season’ contenders atleast every 3 games or so (I mean, seriously… Go back and watch some of his saves between 2014 to 2017 and you’ll see why I’m holding him in such high regard). Unfortunately, once you’ve garnished a reputation as a GK who tends to make mistakes, it becomes quite difficult to rid yourself from being associated with blunders and De Gea suffered from some highly publicized errors during the latter stages of his United career which could’ve been one of the major reasons behind him still being a free agent currently within 2024. Regardless of this, we still have a spot for David within this team, and he will be responsible for simply stopping the ball from going in the back of his net. In addition, even though David has recently converted from a ’95’ rated GK in his pump to a now ’90’ rated one, those shot stopping reflexes have never left him and there’s a match winner in there somewhere…


In front of De Gea, we have what might be the youngest back 5 within our mini series to date. We start off dead centre with the Brazilain stalwart Gleison Bremer who has been quietly going under the radar as one of the better Brazilian ‘no nonsense’ D(C)’s who’s currently a mainstay at Juventus who have been riddled with scandal after scandal over the past few seasons… Although Brazil doesn’t necessarily focus on developing ‘Stoppers’, there have been some really good ones over the past 20 years with former players like Lucio, Juan Jesus, Alex, and the current crop like Gabriel Magalhães, Diego Carlos and the aforementioned Bremer. He will do a similar role to Acerbi (from the 5-3-2C epsiode) in that they don’t apply that much finesse on the ball but are solely responsible for the orchestrating of where each player has to be in order to make the defence diffucult to break down. To his right and left, we have the ball progressers, and what players we have in the Argentinian who has really found his feet at Villareal, and the Ducthman who has the world at his feet and represents total football to its optimum. Juan Foyth (the Argentine) started his career at Estudiantes before being quickly swooped up by Tottenham Hotspur where he gained a reputation as a decent ‘Fullback’. He was unfortunately too fragile for the intensity of the premier league and therefore moved to Villarreal in 2020 and has really never looked back, becoming an integral part of the team that won the Europa league back in 2021. Jurrien Timber (the Dutchman) has long time been a player that was touted for great things and would showcase his radical versatility via the youth set up at Ajax where it was stated that he played in 6 different positions comfortably before making the defence his home. He will be the one responsible for both progressive passing and dribbling, while Foyth will be the one primarily responsible for dribbling but can also provide an ‘overlap’ or ‘underlap’ if necessary.

We have two 89 rated ‘Wingbacks’ out-wide who provide different options on the ball with the Norwegian Julian Ryerson (who I always thought was American) being the dribbling and off the ball maneuver, while the German Robin Gosens (who has always been a German) is more of the crosser who continues the trend of German ‘Wingbacks’ that possess brilliant ball striking skills

MIDFIELD

Since Soccermanager decided to make this formation look more similar to the 5-2-3, we’ve decided to set it up in a way that is the actual realistic positional system that you will find in real life soccer, with the 2 M(C)’ s being joined by 2 players out-wide. We start off with the men in the middle and we’ve got some creative ballers who have been revolutionized in different roles that they started their professional career in. Hakan Çalhanoğlu has for a long time been a player that has been raved for his elite ball striking (he’s arguably top 3 in the world when it comes to set pieces). He started his professional career as an M(C),(RLC) who possessed that killer ball in both open and dead ball siuations, and was particularly effective as a ‘Wide Midfielder’ staying out-wide and looking to get crosses into the box in a similar mold to a David Beckham. After the death of these type of players, Hakan was then converted to a ‘Creative No.10’ who would be the main creator for his team playing in behind of the main F(C). As the game progressed to nullify the impact of ‘No.10’s and with Hakan not being the most complete in terms of his technical dribbling capability, Simone Inzaghi signed him from bitter rivals AC Milan and immediately used Hakan’s engine and ball playing skills via playing him slightly deeper in the midfield, and he just kept going deeper and deeper until he landed in his current role as a ‘Deep-lying Playmaker’ for club and country (albeit he sometimes plays slightly higher for Turkey).

In Exequiel Palacios we have a player who is one of the biggest beneficiaries of “Alonso ball” at Bayer Leverkusen and he has been nothing short of sensational for the current Bundesliga leaders. He has always had a knack for a pass but was considered more of a ‘No.10’ during his earlier days at River Plate and for the Argentina youth teams. But he also possessed an abundance of high energy off the ball and was converted into a ‘Technical B2B’ during his developmental stage at Leverkusen, and now he operates primarily as a central ‘Playmaker’ who also gets around the pitch therefore mixing both of his previous roles well (Palacios is also quite similar to other players like Luka Modrić, Dani Ceballos, Christian Erisken, Paul Pogba in terms of his current style of play…)

Out-wide, we have two players who will provide a completely different profile whilst on the ball in Samuel Chukwueze, who is as direct as they get with his love for running past players for fun, while Federico Chiesa will cause his ‘Fullback’ nightmares with his off the ball movement (especially those ‘in behind’ runs).

FORWARD

If it’s one thing that the 5-4-1’s need is a player who can hold it up and bring other players into the game and we have just the right player for this in the Guinea Superstar, Serhou Guirassy. Serhou has been one of the most talked about F(C)’s in Europe’s top 5 leagues due to him tearing up the Bundesliga as the 2nd top goal scorer for the 23/24 season so far. He is a traditional ‘R.T.M’ that does the usual hardworking stuff, displaying all of his physical and aerial prowess for everyone to see in addition to also knowing where the back of the net is. With the likes of Palacios, Chukwueze, and Chiesa all looking to get in and around the box, and with the service that is being provided by Ryerson and Gosens from out-wide, we can expect Guirassy to lead the line well as our main “bags” man!

DEFENSIVE TRANSITION

We don’t have to worry aout this compartment when it comes to the 5-4-1’s since it will be quite the task for any team to break them down. But I personally believe that the ‘B’ side is slightly better due to an extra bit of variety in terms of the midfield 4 being able to switch up their press with Chukwueze and Chiesa joining Guirassy to form a mid block front 3, or they can maintain their out-wide positions, getting tight alongside their M(C) two in order to make penetration from the opps almost impossible…

It’s the final stretch from this point soccermanagerites. Season 9’s finish line will be crossed this Friday…

Leave a comment